Corporate Governance and Administrative / Environmental Laws
標準~45 min7 terms12 past questions
Goals of this unit
Tell corporate governance apart from the internal control reporting system: one is a framework for overseeing management, the other a system for confirming that financial reporting is reliable.
Explain whom the Whistleblower Protection Act protects and how, and from whom and for which documents the Information Disclosure Act lets anyone request disclosure.
Sort environment-related laws by purpose: proper disposal of unwanted materials, circulation of resources, or the shift to decarbonization.
Corporate governance (コーポレートガバナンス) is the mechanism by which shareholders, the board of directors and others watch whether management runs the company in line with its purpose and its investors' interests, and correct it when necessary.
Examples of mechanisms that oversee management
General shareholders' meeting: elects directors and corporate auditors
Board of directors: oversees management decisions
Outside directors: give opinions from a position independent of the company
Corporate auditors: audit how directors perform their duties
Separating the role of overseeing management from the role of running the business, and placing people free from internal interests on the overseeing side, curbs unchecked or fraudulent conduct by management. Concrete measures include adding outside directors with no ties to the company or its executives to the board, and having corporate auditors audit how directors carry out their duties. In Japan, beyond the corporate bodies prescribed by the Companies Act, the Corporate Governance Code for listed companies sets out principles for this approach.
AnalogyIt is like a lookout sent by the shipowner checking from the deck that the captain has not strayed off course.
How to rememberGovernance comes from a Latin word meaning 'to steer'. Link it to a mechanism that checks whether the company's helm is being steered properly.
Exam points
ExamA typical way to strengthen oversight of management is to appoint independent outside directors (社外取締役) with no ties to the company or its executives, bringing an outside perspective to the board.
ExamAssessing governance means looking at whether the board actually fulfills its oversight role (effectiveness, 実効性). Corporate auditors (監査役) are the body that audits how directors carry out their duties.
Mix-upCompliance (コンプライアンス) means a company observing laws and social norms, whereas corporate governance (コーポレートガバナンス) is the mechanism for overseeing management's decisions and actions.
The Whistleblower Protection Act (公益通報者保護法) shields workers and other whistleblowers from dismissal and other unfavorable treatment when they report their employer's violations of law to a recipient the Act designates.
A legal violation at the workplace
Report to a recipient set by the Act
Dismissal void, unfavorable treatment banned
Any dismissal triggered by the report is void, and demotion, pay cuts and similar treatment are prohibited too.
3 / 3
Possible recipients include the employer's internal hotline, an administrative body with authority over the matter, and outside parties such as the media, and the further outside the recipient, the stricter the conditions for protection. The aim is to let insiders who know of wrongdoing speak up without fear, so that corporate misconduct is found and corrected early. A 2020 amendment, in force from 2022, extended protection beyond workers to people within one year of leaving the job and to officers.
AnalogyIt is like a rule that keeps a player who reports a foul to the referee from being benched for having spoken up.
How to rememberSplit the Japanese name into 'public interest' (公益), 'whistleblower' (通報者) and 'protection' (保護), and the purpose, who is protected and the effect can be read straight off it.
Exam points
ExamThe Whistleblower Protection Act (公益通報者保護法) makes any dismissal triggered by a report void and also prohibits unfavorable treatment such as demotion or pay cuts.
ExamProtected workers (労働者) are not distinguished by employment type, so people who are not regular employees are covered too.
ExamProtection presupposes reporting a legal violation involving one's employer to a recipient designated by the Act (通報先).
The internal control reporting system (内部統制報告制度) requires management of listed companies to assess whether the financial-reporting part of their in-house mechanisms for running operations properly (internal control) works effectively, and to disclose the result as an internal control report.
Management assesses internal control over financial reporting
Prepare the internal control report
An external auditor audits it
Disclose to investors
Once the report is disclosed, investors can make decisions based on reliable financial information.
4 / 4
In Japan it began in fiscal 2008 under the Financial Instruments and Exchange Act, and because it was modeled on the US SOX Act it is also called J-SOX. The report is audited by a certified public accountant or audit firm, so management's self-assessment is checked by outside eyes. The aim is to prevent false financial information from window dressing and the like and to keep capital markets sound.
AnalogyIt is like a store manager checking that the shop's cash-handling procedures are followed, then having an outside inspector with no stake in the shop confirm that the check was right.
How to rememberThe J in J-SOX stands for Japan. Remembering it as the Japanese version of the US SOX Act also reminds you that its legal basis is a securities market law.
Exam points
ExamThe internal control reporting system (内部統制報告制度) exists to keep financial disclosure accurate, protecting investors and keeping capital markets sound.
ExamThe legal basis of the internal control reporting system is the Financial Instruments and Exchange Act (金融商品取引法). By contrast, it is the Companies Act (会社法) that requires certain companies to set up systems ensuring that directors' duties comply with the law.
The Information Disclosure Act (情報公開法) is the law that lets anyone request disclosure of administrative documents held by national administrative organs and sets out the procedure for doing so.
Request disclosure
Check for non-disclosure information
Decide: disclose, partly disclose, or withhold
Disclosure is the rule, and only the parts containing non-disclosure information may be blacked out.
3 / 3
Its formal name is the Act on Access to Information Held by Administrative Organs, and its purpose is to fulfill the government's duty to explain its activities to the public (accountability). An organ that receives a request must in principle disclose, but information that can identify individuals or that would harm a corporation's legitimate interests if made public is excluded as non-disclosure information. Documents held by local governments are handled by each one's own information disclosure ordinance.
How to rememberThe one doing the disclosing is the national administrative organ. Remember it by the subject: the duty to open up lies not with the requester but with the government body that holds the documents.
Exam points
ExamWhat can be requested under the Information Disclosure Act (情報公開法) are administrative documents (行政文書) that officials of an administrative organ created or obtained in the course of their duties and that the organ holds as an organization.
Mix-upThe Information Disclosure Act has administrative documents disclosed on request, while the procedure for requesting disclosure of personal information about oneself is set out in the Act on the Protection of Personal Information (個人情報保護法).
The Waste Management Act (廃棄物処理法) sets out how waste is to be stored, transported and disposed of, requiring proper treatment to protect the living environment and public health.
Waste
Industrial waste: types set by law that arise from business activities
The business that generated it is responsible for treatment
General waste: everything other than industrial waste (household garbage, etc.)
Municipalities are responsible for waste from households
Its formal name is the Act on Waste Management and Public Cleansing. Waste is divided into industrial waste, the legally specified types that arise from business activities, and general waste, which covers everything else, and businesses must treat the industrial waste they generate on their own responsibility (generator responsibility). When a company discards used PCs or servers as waste, it also has to handle them in line with this Act.
AnalogyIt is like a town agreeing in advance on how garbage is put out, carried away and where it ends up, so that nobody dumps it by the roadside.
How to rememberThe 'public cleansing' at the end of its formal name is a holdover from an older law on keeping towns clean.
Exam points
Mix-upThe Waste Management Act (廃棄物処理法) requires the proper treatment of things no longer needed, while having used products collected and reused as resources is the job of the recycling acts (リサイクル法).
Recycling acts (リサイクル法) is a collective name for several laws, each set for a particular item category, that have used products and containers collected and reused as resources.
Example items
Main law
Home appliances such as air conditioners and TVs
Home Appliance Recycling Act
Personal computers
Act on the Promotion of Effective Utilization of Resources (manufacturers collect and recycle)
Small appliances such as mobile phones
Small Home Appliance Recycling Act
Containers and packaging such as glass and PET bottles
Containers and Packaging Recycling Act
The underlying Basic Act on Establishing a Sound Material-Cycle Society sets the order of priority: first reduce waste, then reuse things, then recycle them as resources. On that basis, separate laws for items such as home appliances, PCs, and containers and packaging decide who collects them and who bears the cost.
Exam points
Mix-upThe term recycling acts (リサイクル法) is usually used not as the name of a single law but as a collective name for laws set by item category, such as home appliances or containers and packaging.
Waste Management Act vs. Recycling acts
Aspect
Waste Management Act
Recycling acts
Key differencePurpose
Treat things no longer needed properly and protect the living environment
Have used items collected and reused as resources
Form of law
A single law
Collective name for item-specific laws
Link to IT equipment
How a company must treat equipment it discards as waste
Manufacturers collect and recycle PCs and similar items
The GX Promotion Act (GX推進法) uses national strategy and investment mechanisms to drive GX (green transformation), which pairs decarbonization, meaning cuts in greenhouse gas emissions, with economic growth.
Industry and society reliant on fossil fuels
National strategy, investment, pricing emissions
Decarbonization alongside economic growth
GX refers to efforts to shift industrial and social structures that rely on fossil fuels toward clean energy. The law passed in 2023, formally the Act on Promotion of a Smooth Transition to a Decarbonized Growth-Oriented Economic Structure, provides for, among other things, a government GX promotion strategy, government bonds (GX economy transition bonds) issued to support decarbonization investment up front, and the phased introduction of carbon pricing, which puts a price on carbon dioxide emissions.
How to rememberThe X in GX stands for the 'trans' (meaning 'across', read as 'cross') in transformation, the same convention as in DX.
Exam points
Mix-upWhereas the Waste Management Act (廃棄物処理法) and the recycling acts (リサイクル法) deal with disposing of things and circulating resources, the GX Promotion Act (GX推進法) deals with decarbonization through transforming energy and industrial structures.
Key points
In corporate governance, shareholders and the board of directors oversee management, supported by highly independent outside directors and by corporate auditors who audit directors' duties.
The Whistleblower Protection Act protects workers and others who report their employer's legal violations to a recipient set by the Act, and makes dismissal triggered by the report void.
The internal control reporting system, based on the Financial Instruments and Exchange Act, confirms the reliability of financial reporting through management's assessment and an external auditor's audit.
Under the Information Disclosure Act, anyone can request that national administrative organs disclose administrative documents, with non-disclosure information such as data identifying individuals excluded as an exception.